To Help The Red Cross Click Here
Mother-In-Law Mall
A place to find great gifts!
and products related to mothers-in-law and other family members.

 
mother-in-law stories bd10358.gif
Back To Mother-In-Law Stories Home Page
Mother-In-Law Stories

July 19, 2003
mother-in-law stories bd10358.gif

 
JUNE 2003
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
JULY 2003
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Worst gift:  You think that your presents from your MILs are bad?  How about receiving a bag of used underwear and bras from your MIL's friend?  I sent them right back to her.  If she wanted to do something nice, she could have bought one pair of nice undies instead!

        Signed - Not That Desperate

0
                                    1 0                    
Strongly Agree 
                                                           
Somewhat Agree 
                                                           
Somewhat Disagree 
                                                           
Strongly Disagree 
                                                           
Please Seek Counseling 
                                                           
Continue on Message Board 
                                                           

Worst gift:  I was married in the fall of 2002, and my sisters gave me a beautiful bridal shower during the summer before the wedding.  I was the first person in my family to register.  It is a great idea, and people will buy you what you really want.  Well, not my dear MIL and SIL (they couldn't afford their own gift, so they had to put their name on hers).  She decided to buy us a 7 quart mixer with a blender attachment (mind you, so there is currently only two of us).  This thing is larger than the one they use on TV cooking shows (when they cook for the whole audience).  Mind you, I did not even have a mixer on my registry.  This thing is so tremendous, it does not fit on a counter or in a cabinet.  She was so proud of this that she insisted I open it last.  When I did, I loudly said, "This wasn't on my registry."  She replied, "I know, but it is great.  You can use it so much (that's right, because my name is Betty Crocker), and DH can buy you all the attachments."  Yeah, like that is what I want from DH for my birthday or Christmas.  I still have it in the box, and I am considering returning it.  Needless to say, this is the only thing that she has ever given me in the three years that I have been with DH.  I feel so loved!!!

        Signed - 7 Quarts

        Per the poster's request, no responses collected.

Am I overreacting?  Someone let me know.  My MIL is the needy type.  My DH is the type who doesn't want to piss off his mother for any reason at all, even if she needs to hear the truth.  Whenever MIL disrespects me, he doesn't say anything to her about it.  She's self-centered.  If it's not done her way, all he!! breaks loose.  DH only calls MIL when I'm not around.  MIL talks to DH in a baby voice.  When DH and I were deciding on our baby's name, I told MIL that it was going to be one name at first, but then we decided on another name.  She screamed, "Well, I like the first name!"  I wanted to choke her.  Three weeks after I had the baby, MIL told me that my cheeks were fat, in front of DH's whole family.  She said that the reason my baby had gas in the beginning was because I didn't know how tight to place the bottle cap on.  This was all in front of my DH, and he didn't say a word!  He tried to ignore everything.  In addition to that being on my mind, my DH is different than he was when we got married 4 years ago.  He WAS very romantic, bought me lots of things, constantly told me that he loved me, all that good stuff.  Now, there is no romance, no flowers, no cuddling, no massages, no hugs, no nothing.  DH gives me the silent treatment sometimes, which hurts very badly.  I feel like I'm losing the love for him that I once had.  I've talked to him about it, but no changes have taken place.  Although he has promised, time and time again, that things will change.  I refuse to see MIL, or even talk to her, until she respects me.  I can't take it anymore.  What should I do?

        Signed - Fed Up!!!!!

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
Ask DH if he and MIL where the same size skirt.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
Seriously, leave!  You get no respect from your DH or your MIL.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
You married a man who does not respect you or support you.  Figure out if that's the way you want to live your life.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
Get counseling, or leave.  He's not ready to cut the apron strings from his mama.  You and his child are his family and his priority, not his mother.  HIS MOTHER KNOWS THIS.  I can guarantee, because I bet that if her DH had treated her the same way, she would've had a fit, wouldn't she?

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
You need to stress less on what is happening with your in-laws right now, and try to get things right with DH.  Sit him down and ask him what gives???  If it is something y'all can work out, then do so.  If it is not, then you need to start making plans to move on, as there are plenty of nontoxic relationships out there that don't involve head games.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
C O U N S E L I N G !!!  If your DH will join you, great.  But if not, go yourself.  A counselor/therapist can help you cope with the hurt of your disappointment, the bad treatment you have gotten from MIL and DH, and the anxiety you must have over the future of your marriage.  Something is very wrong for a person to change THAT much - your DH really, really, really needs counseling, too, but if he isn't willing, then focus on getting help and support for YOURSELF.  Best of luck.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
A new baby can put a strain on even the best marriage.  Unfortunately, it is your husband (not MIL) who is your biggest problem right now, because of his inability to set healthy boundaries with his mother, regardless of the fallout.  Your marriage sounds like it's worth saving, but some objective, outside support is required. This, of course, requires the cooperation of both parties.  Please seek counseling.  If DH won't go with you, if he can't or won't understand that his marriage is on the line, you may want to rethink your future.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
Continue to avoid MIL.  Why be around someone who treats you like cr@p?  You are doing the right thing.  DH is a huge problem, though, even bigger than MIL.  DH should be putting you first.  Right now he is putting mommmmmyyyyyyy's feelings before yours.  Get him to counseling, ASAP!  If he won't go, go for yourself.  Tell DH to shape up or ship out.

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
You and DH need counseling, and your DH needs to be present with you.  He also needs to grow a pair of balls when it comes to his mother, because he is supposed to be a married man, and his first priority is you and that baby, not his mommy.  He shouldn't let her walk all over you like that.  He is a coward who isn't standing up for or protecting his family when he lets his mother berate you and act like she is in control.  Why in the world do you let her get away with it????  It's your DH's place as a man to talk to his own parents, not you.  But, it would be a cold day in he!! when I would let MIL get away with saying something like that in front of family.  The best thing that you can ever say to someone who insults you in front of people is to ask them what they said again, and make them have to repeat themselves.  Keep doing it until they get your point.  You don't have to bow down to his mother or keep quiet when he isn't man enough to stand up for you.  Maybe you should point that out to her the next time he just cowers in the corner and she starts being nasty to you.  Tell her that you have no choice but to defend yourself, because her son isn't man enough to deal with his family.  I don't doubt that your DH feels or acts the way he does.  Why would he feel good or act romantic towards the person whom he lets his mother walk all over!!!!  He's a let down, and a failure to your marriage, until he gets his priorities straight and becomes a man - not a scared little momma's boy.  DH would physically remove his mother from the room if she kept saying stuff like that to me, because I'm his wife and the person with whom he chose to live for the rest of his life.  And, that calls for major respect from his family, that's why!!!

RESPONSE:  Fed Up!!!!!
Oh dear, I so feel for you!  Your DH must be my DH's twin, and your MIL is my MIL's long lost identical twin!  When I was pregnant with my first baby, I was very excited, and bought a book of baby's names to make sure that I gave my baby a really good and meaningful name.  In the hospital, after my painful emergency C-section, DH was on the phone with his parents, telling them the good news.  I half heard part of the conversation, but as soon as he put the phone down, he turned to me and said, "Well, the baby's name is ABCD."  What the #$%@??????  This was my baby, wasn't it?  That is how manipulating they are, and how DH would jump when they mention the word jump.  Then, when I was pregnant with my second son, I chose the names very early on.  This time, we were living near them.  My MIL was there in the room when they wheeled me back after yet another c-section.  She brought out a piece of paper and gave it to me and said, "FIL and I have been discussing names for the baby.  Since we know it's a boy, here's the list."  I looked at the list and I hated all of them, and I am most positive that my son would, too, once he understands things.  They were names that are so - urgh.  Anyway, this time I was not in so much pain, as I was on an epidural.  I politely told her that I've already chosen a name.  She then told me, "Oh, but we must let FIL approve this name first, for fear it might mean something bad."  What the #$#%????  I told her, "I chose the name because of it's religious meanings.  How can that be bad?"  She said that we should let FIL decide.  Gggrrrrrr.  Then, when I was pregnant with my 3rd baby, a girl this time, she was going on and on about baby's names.  Once, during a family gathering my DH's older sister's kids (a girl and a boy, ages then 10 and 12) had gotten into it, too.  They were suggesting names, too, and discussing what I should name the baby, right in front of everybody!!!!!  I tried to ignore them.  Finally, they agreed on a name, and my DH's nephew announced that the baby's name is DEFG.  I very politely told him, and I looked only at him when I said this, "Well, XYZ dear, the time will come for you to name your own baby, everyone will have a chance at naming a baby.  Look, GM and GP had named all of their 4 kids on their own.  Your mom and dad named the both of you.  You will have your chance.  This is my baby, and I am the mother.  I am the one carrying this baby, and I will have to look after her for the rest of my life.  And so, your uncle and I will name the baby."  LOLOLOLLLLLLL!!!!!!  Still, she pestered me about what name had I chosen, BUT I wouldn't tell.  Right after the birth, she again wanted the name to be approved by FIL.  I politely told her that I have had the name approved by the religious department, and that it is a good name and it means well.  Ha ha!  Still, they needed to have the upper hand.  MY FIL changed the spelling of my daughter's name.  And my DH, being the filial son that he is, followed that spelling.  Oh, have I also told you that my eldest son's spelling was wrong?  And, that it wasn't spelled as in one of the prophet's name.  I did point it out when he was filling out the register, but he disagreed, and told me that was just the way his grandfather's name was spelled.  Okay, now a fourth child.  I was, by this time, a little bit amazed, and I wondered, "Wasn't my DH interested in naming his own babies?"  He was never interested in the names that I considered, and didn't even look at the 2 baby names books that I bought.  So, this time I asked my eldest son to choose a name for the baby.  This time, she didn't come to the hospital to visit.  On the afternoon that I was discharged, while I was at the hospital, she called and asked where DH was, because she had cooked up a storm, and expected him and my kids to eat lunch there.  I reminded her that I was about to be discharged, and would not like to wait in the hospital lobby for 3 hrs. while they have lunch.  She wanted us all to go there.  Gggrggrgrgrrrrrrr, no way.  I put my foot down this time.  I just had my c-section, I had 3 other little kids, and I was going back to my own house and with no help.  It wasn't going to be added to with more headaches.  Hmph.  And, what did they say about my latest daughter's name?????  STRANGE.  Strange my @ss!!!!!!!!  I have lots of stories, and this is just the "naming" part.  My MIL and FIL can't leave my DH alone and they treat him like their little kid. They order him to bring them here and there and everything.  Shrugged.

I thought that my MIL had gotten the message after months of us not showing up at her door.  I should have known better!!!  I gave birth 2 months ago to a healthy baby girl, and I was having problems walking (and all sorts of other things) due to DD being overdue.  It made it even more difficult to have to chase after my 1 year old son at the same time.  We gave her everything from stupid excuses to downright truthful answers as to why we didn't want to come down or have her and her friends show up at our home.  When my daughter was born, nobody called her or gave her a hint that I'd had her till my DH accidentally let it slip at her home one day while visiting his dad.  We love FIL, just not MIL.  I would have let her come down here to let her see her new grandchild, since I wasn't going to be alone with her.  I had back pains and other problems after the birth, and I had a friend there to help me during the day with my son.  She never called or showed up at all till Easter weekend.  They called then to say that they got a video camera and were going to come down.  We had just gotten the internet and didn't want her to know that we had it, so we raced up with the kids to see her (by this time I was able to care for both kids on my own).  If she knew, she would bother me constantly and send me stupid emails, trying to get me into her religion again.  When we got there, she did her best to love up my kids (they wanted nothing to do with her).  We have not been up since that day.  While I was breastfeeding my daughter (yes, my DH and relatives support me in this!!!) in MIL's deep seated futon, I was unable to get out of it to reach my son who was reaching for her scissors.  She took him over her knee and spanked him so hard that his little body actually jumped.  I was steaming and gave her a look that made her put my son back down, and she wouldn't look me in the eye afterward.  I told my DH later, since he was at the car with his father when it happened.  We have not been there as a family since.  Just recently, my DH went up to ask his father for a few extra bucks for gas, since he had a lousy workweek the week before.  Her doctor wanted to have her committed, since she was saying that she was suicidal.  She has been saying this, since I met her, just to get attention.  She asked DH if he could bring the kids and me up to her home to spend the day with her so that we could chat like we used to when we lived with her.  The only reason we did chat was BECAUSE we lived with her, and she would follow me all around the house.  Or, she would get on the Internet when I was on it, and we chatted back and forth.  Someone called Children's Services on me recently, and they respond not too kindly to anyone taking their kids to see unstable relatives.  So, she won't get to see them anyway before she gets committed to a hospital.  My DH supports me in this, so if she refuses to get help, the longer it will be.  I hope that, once she does this, maybe she will finally get the idea as to why I can't stand her.  Comments and suggestions are welcome.

        Signed - MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
You MIL sounds sad and lonely.  Do you only care about yourself?

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
It sounds like you are overreacting.  By the way, if you can not afford gas, perhaps you should give up the Internet

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
OOh boy, where to begin.  C-O-U-N-S-E-L-I-N-G.  Not just you guys, but the whole lot of you.

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
Why do you want her to get the idea that you can't stand her?  How will that help anything?  It seems that, in my experience, the more my MIL feels that I can't stand her, the worse she acts.  Wouldn't it be better not to try to make her feel bad about herself, but to just try to move in a constructive direction yourself?

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
OMG - are you and your DH nuts?  There is no way in he!! that I would let my ILs lay a hand on my children.  You and your DH should have screamed at her.  There is no way that I would have anything to do with someone who spanked my children.

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
Well, she should not have spanked your child like that, and she may be annoying, but threats of suicide should never be ignored, no matter how frivolous they seem.  No one can read minds, and you can't be sure what's going on in hers.  The reason that she may have followed you around was because she was lonely.  And, apparently, she doesn't see her son much anymore.  How would you feel if your children grew up and started to avoid you?  You say that once she found out about your daughter, she never called till Easter.  She was probably hurt that your DH never told her about her granddaughter.  And, as for trying to get you into her religion, I know it's annoying (I've been there myself), but it's a sign that she cares about you and is trying to "save your soul" or something along that line.  Just be kind to her.

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
I don't think that MIL is the only one in the situation who is a bit "off" in their thinking.  First, when a person talks of suicide, it is a RED FLAG that the person is in a serious state of poor mental health.  Even if she is seeking attention, don't you realize that she was in pretty bad shape if she was talking of taking her own life?  MIL's doctor seems to take it seriously - do you think that you're smarter about these things than her doctor?  The woman is ill and in pain - have a heart.  Second, you don't tell the woman when your daughter is born, you avoid visiting with her for months, and then you expect her to come running out to see you before Easter or at whatever time you finally do feel like letting her visit?  She may be a pain, but she must have feelings!  Third, she may be wrong and interfering to impose her religion on you, but most people do that out of love and concern - they think they are saving your soul or something.  You can TELL her how you feel, instead of hiding your computer!  Anyway, you can block her from sending you unwanted e-mails.  You don't have to bar her from your home to hide your PC.  Finally, and most importantly, I'm not surprised that Child Protective Services have been to see you.  You think that giving your MIL a dirty look is an adequate response to having her whoop your child?  You watched your son reach for scissors, and then watched your MIL beat him, and all you did was throw her a look?  NO chair is too deep to protect your own little, helpless child!!!!  Was the chair so deep that you could only throw a look, and couldn't open your mouth to tell her to stop hitting your son?  The chair thing is an excuse for laziness or stupidity (or both) on your part, and if you think otherwise, you are only fooling yourself.  Maybe it would be more productive for you to focus on how to be a better parent and person yourself, instead of dwelling on what's wrong with your MIL, playing these stupid games with her, and looking forward to the possibility of her being committed.

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
Oh no, that woman would have flown across the room if she laid hands on my baby.  She better be religious, because I would have sent her out of this world back to the one that she came from.  Stay away from people like that.  You don't have to subject yourself to people just because they are ILs.  If you don't like her religion, maybe you should just tell her so, instead of hiding your Internet like a fool from her.  That is just pathetic, and it sounds like you need to be a little more forward with her.  Sometimes you've got to say, "Look lady, I don't like what you are selling, so get lost.  And, if you touch my kid again, I'm going to give you cement shoes."  That will get the point across.  If your husband doesn't like it, tell him that he can join his mother.

RESPONSE:  MIL Finally May Be Committed!!!
You are doing the right thing by keeping your children away from your MIL, especially if she refuses to get herself help.  I can't believe how she treated your little boy.  If she could do that IN FRONT OF YOU, imagine what she would do to him if she got him alone.  My only advice to you is to be more direct with your MIL.  If anyone had done that to my child, I would have been screaming bloody murder.  A "look" isn't going to send her the message that she should never lay her hands on your children.  You have to tell her, in no uncertain terms!


Note:
  To better handle the volume of submissions - stories and responses received will be posted as early as our resources will allow.  Responses to new stories will be accumulated, and then posted, all at once, to the original story page at a later date (generally, one set of responses will be posted per day).
mother-in-law stories bd10358.gif

 


The Sister Knot, Apter
The Sister Knot
Why We Fight, Why We're Jealous, and Why We'll Love Each Other No Matter What


Secret Paths: Women in the New Midlife
Secret Paths
Women in the New Midlife


Working Women Don't Have Wives, Dr. Terri Apter Working Women Don't Have Wives
Professional Success in the 1990'S


To See More Books By
Dr. Terri Apter
Click Here.


           Back To The Top - Click Here

Search this site or the web powered by FreeFind
    

Site search Web search


DISCLAIMER: 
All advice on this website is for informational and entertainment purposes only.  All responses are from reader submissions unless specifically noted otherwise (such as Dr. Terri Apter advice page).  We do not endorse any of the advice.  We provide it to you as a service.  We can neither guarantee the soundness of the advice, nor make any claims as to the outcome of following this advice.  We provide it for your entertainment only.  Should you choose to follow any of the advice, it is solely at your own risk.  This is not intended to substitute for obtaining advice from appropriate sources and/or professional counseling.  We recommend you consult an appropriate professional, counselor, and/or a trusted advisor before taking any action based on this advice.  B A Squared, LLC and www.motherinlawstories.com make no representations or guarantees regarding any information dispensed on this site.

Your privacy is important to us.  Click here to view our Privacy Policy.

Copyright © 1999 - 2010, B A Squared, LLC.  All rights reserved.  Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of B A Squared, LLC is strictly prohibited.  All materials submitted (written or otherwise) to www.motherinlawstories.com become the property of B A Squared, LLC.  Submission of any material (written or otherwise) constitutes your permission for B A Squared, LLC to use, edit, reproduce and publish this material (in whole or in part) in any way it deems appropriate, and releases B A Squared, LLC from any and all liability associated with the publication of said material.

CONTACT US: To contact us for any reason, please use the email form on our Help Page which you can get to by clicking here, or email us at webmaster@motherinlawstories.com.